Bialetti Stainless Steel VS Aluminum: Which Is Better?

When deciding between Bialetti stainless steel vs aluminum, are you swayed by other people’s opinion? If yes, here’s how I picked mine.

Heads up, gorgeous. Some links you see here are affiliate links. If you click and buy something, I might get a coffee (or two) out of it. The price stays the same for you, promise.

My coffee break routine has helped me prevent digital burnout. And my Bialetti moka pot has been a huge part of it. But I went through some serious inner debate as I decided between Bialetti stainless steel vs aluminum. Here’s what I found out about each type based on my experience:

Stainless Steel Moka Pot

Bialetti’s stainless steel model isn’t exactly new on the market, but for a while, I resisted. It just seemed… a bit too serious, a bit too polished. Who needed that?

After experimenting with both, I found myself leaning toward the stainless steel version. The benefits aren’t just in the look (though it does have a charm).

Why I Like It:

• Durability: This thing could probably survive a minor apocalypse.
• Taste: The material does not absorb odors, so the coffee tastes a bit cleaner.
• No Coating Worries: You don’t have to worry about the material breaking down or releasing undesirable chemicals.

Why I Hate It:

• Cleaning: It’s a little more time-consuming than aluminum. You can’t just give it a quick rinse and call it a day.
• Weight: It’s heavy. It almost feels like I’m lifting a dumbbell when I pour the coffee.
• Price: You’re paying for that extra durability and elegant design.

Aluminum Moka Pot

It’s like an old friend you don’t mind seeing every morning, even if they’re a little worn-out. I swore by the aluminum version before I became a stainless steel convert. It was light, affordable, and everything I needed.

Why I Like It:

• Lightweight: No muscle workout needed. It’s easy to handle and pour.
• Affordability: It’s the cheap and cheerful option.
• Speed: It heats up faster than the stainless steel version. For those hectic mornings, that’s a nice little perk.
• Classic Look: It’s what you think of when you visualize a traditional Moka pot.

Why I Hate It:

• Scratches Easily: It’s not as tolerant when it comes to dents or scratches.
• Not Induction-Friendly: This is a dealbreaker if you use an induction stove.
• Reacts with Acidity: If you’re brewing a lot of dark roasts, the aluminum can impart a metallic after a while.
• Needs Care: It needs to be treated with more care than the stainless steel version.

Now, there’s some chatter about aluminum leaching and potential health concerns. The research is ongoing, and frankly, a little inconclusive.

What to Pick: Bialetti Stainless Steel vs Aluminum?

When I first picked between Bialetti stainless steel vs aluminum, I realized that my choice was shaped by subtle social cues. Now that I’ve owned both, the stainless steel version has become my go-to. Here are some things to consider so you can decide based on product traits:

Considerations:

• What’s Your Stove? If you have an induction stove, you’ll want the stainless steel version. Aluminum won’t work.
• Budget: If you’re on a budget, the aluminum version is a reliable option. It’s inexpensive and still brews a decent cup.
• How Long Do You Want It to Last? The stainless steel version is more likely to endure a move across countries

When deciding between Bialetti stainless steel vs aluminum, don’t fall into the trap of introjection. Don’t let your choice be a reflection of someone else’s image.

Read: What Size Moka Pot is Best for One Person?

FAQs